Catholic Gifts and More Reviews
Catholic Gifts and More has an overall rating of 2.1 based on 29 reviews. Customer feedback on Catholic Gifts and More is mixed.
29 reviews
5 Stars
1
4 Stars
1
3 Stars
10
2 Stars
5
1 Star
12
How would you rate Catholic Gifts and More?
All Catholic Gifts and More Reviews (29)
ShantelMarmo_37
June 01, 2026
"Exchange worked, but the canned apologies got old"
I ordered a gift from Catholic Gifts and More and ended up needing to exchange it for something else. It did get handled in the end, so I’ll give them that, but it took more emails than I expected and felt slower than it should have. The staff was polite enough, but I kept getting those canned “sorry for the inconvenience” type replies, which just made it more annoying. Overall, not a terrible experience, but I really wish their return and exchange process was smoother
0
Reply
annebowers0804
May 30, 2026
"I was ready to buy, but the payment..."
I was ready to buy, but the payment step just didn’t feel very safe to me. Maybe I’m being extra cautious, but when it comes to entering card details, I need the checkout to look and feel trustworthy. I ended up backing out instead.
0
Reply
agnes-Hogan
May 29, 2026
"Looks just like the picture"
I’ll be honest, after I paid I got a little suspicious and started wondering if it was actually going to look like the photos. But when it arrived, I was really relieved. The colors and details were pretty much exactly the same in person, with no weird surprises. It’s always nice when an online order turns out the way you hoped. I’d order from Catholic Gifts and More again
0
Reply
christine_Love91
May 25, 2026
"Refund came through, just took a while"
I did end up getting my refund, so that was good. I was a little stressed at the time because it took longer than I expected, and support only replied once. Everything worked out in the end, but quicker updates would’ve made the wait feel a lot easier.
0
Reply
hello_sean093
May 23, 2026
"I had a simple question about my..."
I had a simple question about my order and it took them days to reply?! not the best experience when you’re just trying to get an update
0
Reply
seanferraro0243
April 18, 2026
"I reached out to customer service with..."
I reached out to customer service with what I thought was a simple question about my order, but the replies I got were super short and not really useful. Maybe I’m assuming too much from the tone, but it felt like they just wanted me to stop asking instead of actually helping. It was frustrating, and I don’t think I’d order from here again
0
Reply
Florence.harrison
April 05, 2026
"I ordered this as a gift because..."
I ordered this as a gift because it looked like it was in stock, so I went ahead and paid for it. Not long after, I found out it was actually backordered, which was really frustrating. It ended up taking way longer than I expected, and the updates were minimal. I felt like I had to keep reaching out just to find out what was going on. Overall, not a great experience
0
Reply
Kathryn_shavers96
April 02, 2026
"Sizing was a little tricky"
I ordered a shirt and, uh, the design was really nice, but the fit ended up being a bit smaller than I expected. It wasn’t a huge deal or anything, just... I do wish the sizing chart had been a little clearer before I bought it.
0
Reply
gladysgorman8544
March 28, 2026
"Not at all what I expected"
I ordered this sometime last month, or maybe it was the end of the month before, and it looked nothing like the description. I was disappointed when it showed up because it just wasn’t even close to what I thought I was getting
0
Reply
michael1971
March 25, 2026
"A little too expensive for me"
I wanted to like this place, but the prices just felt high compared to similar shops nearby. It’s not even about paying a bit more if the value is there, but I didn’t really feel like there was enough difference to justify it.
0
Reply
hello_brandon604
March 24, 2026
"The box showed up crushed..."
The box showed up crushed, and right away something felt off. When I opened it, the item had scratches on it too. It just didn’t seem like it was packed or handled very carefully...
0
Reply
Charles_wilson73
March 23, 2026
"Arrived scratched, so check yours right away"
Just a heads up for anyone ordering this: mine showed up with the box dented, and the item had some scratches on it. It wasn’t the worst damage ever, but still disappointing. I’d definitely recommend checking it carefully as soon as it arrives.
0
Reply
jeremy_Duggan84
March 08, 2026
"A lot was out of stock"
I was hoping to grab a few things, but a lot of the items I wanted were unavailable, kind of disappointing, honestly...
0
Reply
Rose_siegel05
February 21, 2026
"Delivery was a little hit or miss"
The package showed up later than expected, which was a bit frustrating. Reading between the lines, it seemed like there may have been some delay in the delivery process, but at least it arrived in good shape in the end.
0
Reply
SCOTT
February 15, 2026
"Ordering went through fine in the end, so..."
Ordering went through fine in the end, so no big issue there. But am I the only one who found the checkout a little awkward on mobile? I had to double-check my shipping info twice, which slowed things down. Nothing terrible, just not as quick or smooth as I expected.
0
Reply
MichaelCamel
February 12, 2026
"Pretty good communication"
I had a question about my order, and they got back to me fairly quickly. The response was clear and polite, and it did not feel like some generic auto-reply. One update took a bit longer than I thought it would, but it was not a big deal. Overall, I would say the communication was good.
0
Reply
HAITH
February 10, 2026
"Shipping was a bit slow"
My order showed up fine and everything was in good shape, but the shipping took longer than I expected. It wasn’t a total disaster or anything, just slower than other places I’ve ordered from. Kind of ridiculous how long it took for a normal order, honestly
0
Reply
Anne-alexander
February 10, 2026
"I found one item I actually liked..."
I found one item I actually liked, but when I got to checkout, the shipping was just... way too much!!! For such a small order, it felt kind of ridiculous??
0
Reply
jacquelynsagedahl4316
February 03, 2026
"Had to double-check my order"
I wasn’t sure if my order actually went through because the confirmation was so confusing. I ended up having to check my email, refresh the page, and basically do extra digging just to feel like it was placed. Kind of annoying when it should’ve been simple
0
Reply
tamara-Leith
January 30, 2026
"Not really worth the price"
It was okay, but for some reason I was expecting it to feel a little more worth the money. The shipping costs added up too, so overall it ended up feeling expensive. I might consider buying again if there’s a sale, but I probably wouldn’t pay full price
0
Reply
Have a question about Catholic Gifts and More?
Log in to ask your Catholic Gifts and More question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
